Mueller Weiss syndrome, a less elucidated and unusual cause of midfoot pain: A case report
How to cite this article: Joseph VM, Lynser D, Khan AY, Daniala C. Mueller Weiss syndrome, a less elucidated and unusual cause of midfoot pain: A case report. Indian J Musculoskelet Radiol, doi: 10.25259/ IJMSR_47_2020
Mueller Weiss Syndrome is a rare, under-diagnosed cause of chronic mid foot pain despite having well-described imaging features. It is historically described as spontaneous adult-onset osteonecrosis of the navicular bone. The disease commonly affects bilateral navicular bones in women in the fifth decade of life. Nearly a century after its first description as a disease entity, the exact etiopathogenesis is still not well understood. From a radiographic point of view weight-bearing radiographs of the foot remains the mainstay in diagnosis. Characteristic imaging findings include the lateral collapse of navicular, dorsomedial subluxation of the remnant navicular, and lateral deviation of the talus (hind-foot varus). Progressive disease leads to pes planus and secondary osteoarthritis of the talonavicular joint with or without the involvement of other midfoot joints. Severe disease may show “listhesis navicularis” and talo-cuneiform neo-articulation. Computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging can be used as adjuncts, especially to detect changes in the initial stage of the disease and early osteoarthritic features.
Mueller Weiss syndrome
Meary Tomeno angle
Comma shaped deformity
MuellerWeiss Syndrome is the eponym for adult-onset spontaneous osteonecrosis of navicular bone causing mid and hindfoot pain and deformity. Early recognition and management can control symptoms and delay progression of the disease and secondary osteoarthritis. We present a case report of a patient diagnosed with Mueller Weiss Syndrome, having typical imaging features but presenting at a relatively younger age of onset.
A 34-year-old woman presented with insidious onset, progressively increasing bilateral asymmetric dorsomedial midfoot pain for 4 months. There was no history of recent trauma or systemic diseases. On examination, there was swelling and tenderness over the talonavicular joint (Right > Left). Routine blood investigations like complete blood count were unremarkable. The patient underwent weight-bearing radiographs followed by computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging of both feet [Figures 1-3].
Based on an isolated clinical background of bilateral chronic midfoot pain and typical imaging features, the diagnosis of Mueller Weiss Syndrome in this patient is well substantiated. However, being an infrequent cause of this symptom, on a case-to-case basis, there is a need for increased awareness of this entity both among treating clinicians as well as diagnosticians.
Historically, MuellerWeiss Syndrome has been described as spontaneous adult-onset osteonecrosis of the tarsal navicular. The exact etiopathogenesis is unknown, however, studies have proposed that factors leading to persistent lateral loading on a sub-optimally ossified navicular bone which is prone to ischemia is contributory.
Most commonly the presentation is as chronic mid/ hindfoot pain in a middle-aged (40–60 years) female. The presentation was atypical in the above-mentioned case both in terms of age of onset and chronicity, in that, the patient was younger and had a relatively subacute duration of onset of symptoms. Physical examination may reveal high, low, or normal arching of the feet. In this patient, there was maintained plantar arch as evident by physical examination and calculation of Meary Tomeno angle. Imaging features are multiple and hence clarity is achieved if classified based on the anatomic location [Table 1].
|Anatomic part||Involvement in this case|
|Ankle and hindfoot
1. Collapse of the lateral part of the navicular (Comma shaped deformity)
2. Peritalar (medial) subluxation of the navicular (loss of cyma line)
3. Reduction of Talocalcaneal angle
1. Talocuneiform articulation
2. Osteoarthrosis of Talonavicular and Naviculocuneiform Joints
3. Medial subluxation of the cuboid
(with respect to calcaneum)
1. Parallel metatarsals
2. Hypertrophy of second metatarsal
According to the Staging proposed by Maceira and Rochera based on the morphology of the Navicular combined with the Meary Tomeno angle, the patient was staged as bilateral Stage II MuellerWeiss Syndrome [Table 2]. The Staging along with the severity of symptoms, helps the clinicians determine the appropriate line of management.
|Stage of Disease (degree of severity)||Description|
|1. Mild||Radiographs are normal|
|2. Moderate||Dorsolateral subluxation of the talus resulting in cavus and hindfoot varus with rostral angulation of the Meary- Tomeno line|
|3.||Condensation or splitting of the navicular leading to reduction of the longitudinal arch and neutral Meary- Tomeno line|
|4. Severe||Compression of the navicular leading to rearfoot equinus deformity, further reduction of longitudinal arch and caudal angulation of the Meary Tomeno line|
|5.||Talo-cuneiform neoarticulation and expulsion of a disintegrated navicular(“ listhesis navicularis”)|
|Based on the Staging proposed by Maceira and Rochera|
Kohler’s disease is another cause of spontaneous osteonecrosis of navicular bone that is attributed to navicular ossification variant or osteonecrosis. However, Kohler’s disease usually has a childhood-onset (3–7 years), male predominance, unilateral presentation, and a more benign disease progression. Imaging of Kohler’s disease shows flattening of the navicular and a central area of sclerosis that evolves from irregular to progressive uniform redistribution. Navicular stress injury, osteonecrosis secondary to systemic diseases, osteomyelitis, healing phase of traumatic fracture, and initial stages of the neuropathic joint are the other differentials to be considered.[2,6] Most important factor to differentiate Mueller Weiss from this apparently long list of diagnosis, is a detailed clinical history and weight-bearing radiographic findings.
Conservative measures like anti-inflammatory drugs, activity- restriction, and immobilization with orthoses or short leg casts, fail to achieve adequate symptomatic relief in moderate to severe disease and in patients who have developed secondary osteoarthritis. There is a myriad of available surgical options including decompression with or without bone grafting and multiple midfoot arthrodesis but the exact intervention must be tailored to the involvement in the individual patient. Studies have showed satisfactory results with both talonaviculocuneiform arthrodesis with bone grafting and triple fusion arthrodesis. The latter is preferred in patients with additional subtalar and calcaneocuboid joint involvement. However, a standardised surgical option for the management of this disease is not available to date.[7,9]
In a young female patient who presented with a subacute history of bilateral midfoot pain, the diagnosis of MuellerWeiss Syndrome could be clinched owing to its characteristic imaging features of the lateral collapse of navicular with resultant comma-shaped deformity.
Declaration of patient consent
The authors certify that they have obtained all appropriate patient consent.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflict of interest.